Home > Answers > Read Answer

Answer


Please answer: 1) A hadice of reciting “minha khalaqnakum..” while throwing sand in the qabr is mentioned in mirqat vol 4 pg 189, please tell me how authentic it is? 2) The hadith of Abou Hourayrah RA mention in Muwatta imam malik RA about the way we hanafi perform janaza salaah (without surah fatihah), has any of the muhadditheen and fuqaha prove its authenticity? Please give me the references from the books of hadith, jazakum..

الجواب حامداومصليا
Jazakallahu Khaira for providing the reference of Mirqat. I did find the narration in Mirqat of Mulla Ali Qari. Mulla Ali Qari himself wrote that Imam Ahmed has reported this Hadith with a weak narration.
Therefore we learn that the Hadith that is used as a basis for this practice is a weak Hadith.
And Allah knows best.
Mufti Ikram ul Haq
Fatwa Center of America